1858 1c Flying Eagle Cent ANACS F12

This is a classic and historically significant coin, and its grade and certification provide a good idea of its condition and market value.

Let’s break down what each part means:

• 1858 Flying Eagle Cent: This refers to the second and final year of issue for the Flying Eagle Cent series, which was the United States’ first small-sized cent. It replaced the larger, cumbersome copper cents. The series was short-lived, minted only from 1856 (as a pattern, then for general circulation in 1857) to 1858. The 1858 issue is particularly notable for having two distinct varieties:
  • Large Letters (LL): The letters in “AMERICA” on the obverse are closer together. This was the initial design.
  • Small Letters (SL): There is a more noticeable space between the “A” and “M” in “AMERICA.” This variety was introduced later in 1858.

    The specific variety (Large Letters or Small Letters) can impact the coin’s value, with the Small Letters variety often being slightly more valuable, especially in higher grades.

• ANACS: This indicates that the coin has been authenticated and graded by the Analytical and Numerical Coin Grading Service. ANACS is the oldest third-party coin grading service in the United States, established in 1972. They are a reputable service known for their thorough attributions (identifying specific varieties) and for also grading “details” coins (those with problems like cleaning or damage, which they will note on the label).
• F12 (Fine 12): This is the grade assigned to the coin on the Sheldon coin grading scale.
  • “F” for Fine: Signifies that the coin has been in circulation and shows moderate, but even, wear across its entire surface.
  • “12” for the numerical designation: Places it precisely within the “Fine” category.

    For an F12 Flying Eagle Cent, you would expect to see the main design elements clearly outlined, but details such as the eagle’s feathers and the eagle’s eye will be worn flat or nearly flat. The letters in “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” and the date will be complete and readable, but may show some weakness. The rims will be full and distinct from the design, though slightly worn.

Value:

The value of an 1858 Flying Eagle Cent ANACS F12 will depend on which variety it is (Large Letters or Small Letters), as well as the coin’s overall eye appeal (e.g., color, lack of significant distracting marks or toning issues beyond normal circulation).

As of June 2025:

• For an 1858 Flying Eagle Cent (Large Letters) ANACS F12, you can generally expect a value in the range of $50 to $100.
• For an 1858 Flying Eagle Cent (Small Letters) ANACS F12, the value might be slightly higher, often in the range of $60 to $120.

It’s important to remember that these are approximate retail values. Actual prices can vary based on the specific seller (dealer, auction, private sale), buyer demand, and the individual coin’s aesthetic qualities. For the most precise and up-to-date valuations, always consult current price guides from sources like PCGS, NGC, or the Greysheet (CDN Exchange), and look at recent auction results for comparable coins.